China cracks down on free expression in the midst of human rights dialogue with the European Union



Press release RSF
28 September 2004

Reporters Without Borders (Reporters sans frontières) urged European Union
member states and the European Commission to condemn China's latest
crackdown on independent websites and publications at the same time as
holding dialogue on human rights with the EU.

While no announcement has been made on the outcome of the 24 September
meeting in Beijing, the international press freedom organisation urged them
to react to a wave of closures of publications and arrests of journalists.

Beijing appeared to be openly contemptuous of this so-called constructive
dialogue, continuing to shut down outlets for free expression and arresting
hundreds of Chinese people even while European representatives were in the
Chinese capital, it said.

The authorities on 23 September blocked access to the Chinese version of
the Wikipedia online encyclopaedia that relies on contributions from
Internet-users and carries a number of articles about human rights abuses
in China. The site has been blocked on several previous occasions.

One of the country's most popular discussion forums Yi Ta Hu Tu was closed
on 13 September. It was set up by a Beijing university student in September
1999 and had nearly 300,000 regular users. The forum was the focus for
discussion on sensitive issues such as corruption, human rights or the
independence of Taiwan. It operated on a democratic system whereby users
voted on subjects for discussion without interference by moderators, making
it difficult for the authorities to control.

Reporters Without Borders called on the Chinese authorities to reopen the
Yi Ta Hu Tu discussion forum, the Wikipedia site and the thousands of other
sites forbidden to Chinese Internet-users.

The government also closed the diplomatic bimonthly Zhanlue Yu Guanli
(Strategy and Management) in September after it carried an article by
economist Wang Zhongwen in its August issue that was critical of the North
Korean regime

Copies of the magazine carrying the offending article were confiscated and
subscribers were told to return their copies. The magazine lost its
official sponsorship recently despite the fact that its editorial board
included ranking political officials Since June 2004, the Publicity
Department (formerly Propaganda Department) has been trying to shut down
Zhanlue Yu Guanli but its management had succeeded in bringing it out in
July and August.

A China specialist told Reporters Without Borders that that Zhanlue Yu
Guanli, founded in 1993, was one of only around a dozen Chinese
publications to feature debate within the communist party's reformist
intellectual circles. The magazine¹s website www.zlygl.com is still
accessible but the North Korea article does no appear on it.

Reporters Without Borders called on the government to allow Zhanlue Yu
Guanli to resume publishing.

On 17 September, secret service agents arrested journalist Zhao Yan -
recently hired by the New York Times Beijing bureau - while in a Shanghai
restaurant after tracking him down through his mobile phone. Four days
later his family received notice from the police that he had been accused
of "supplying state secrets to foreigners".

His lawyer, who has been refused the right to visit him, said Zhao is being
held in Beijing and could be accused of "treason", a charge that carries
the death penalty.

The authorities appear to suspect him of giving the US daily information
about the resignation of former president Jiang Zemin from his post as
Chairman of the Central Military Commission. The New York Times carried an
article about it on 7 September, 12 days before the official announcement.

The paper denied that Zhao was the source for the article. Foreign desk
head Susan Chira said he had been employed as a researcher and not as a
journalist.  She told Reporters Without Borders that the newspaper's
management hoped the journalist would be allowed to see his lawyer.
Previously a reporter on the magazine China Reform, Zhao is known for his
reports on China's peasantry.

Reporters Without Borders called for his immediate release and recalled
that another journalist, Wu Shishen, has been imprisoned since 1992 for
"illegally divulging state secrets to foreigners". He was sentenced to life
imprisonment on the direct order of Jiang Zemin. He had sent a journalist
in Hong Kong a copy of a speech that the head of state was due to make to
the communist party congress.

Finally, the Chinese press has not reported the demonstrations and arrests
of hundreds of people in Beijing trying to make themselves heard by members
of the central committee attending the communist party plenum during
September. Foreign journalists were also prevented from covering these events.

Hundreds or even thousands of Chinese people, unable to make their
complaints heard through the media, descended on the capital from every
part of the country to try to press their cases. One petitioner from the
province of Xinjiang in the West of the country was killed in mysterious
circumstances in Beijing on 24 September. He had come to the capital to
complain about official ill-treatment of the Uighurs, the ethnic Muslim
group that suffers communist party repression.


========== HURIDOCS-Tech listserv ==========
Send mail intended for the list to <huridocs-tech@hrea.org>.
Archives of the list can be found at:
http://www.hrea.org/lists/huridocs-tech/markup/maillist.php
To subscribe to the list, send a message to <majordomo@hrea.org>,
with the following text in the message: subscribe huridocs-tech
To unsubscribe from the list, send a message to <majordomo@hrea.org>,
with the following text in the message: unsubscribe huridocs-tech
If you have problems (un)subscribing, contact <owner-huridocs-tech@hrea.org>.


[Reply to this message] [Start a new topic] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index] [Subject Index] [List Home Page] [HREA Home Page]