Re: Research and evaluation on impact of HRE



Dear Colleagues,

I have been quietly and silently watching this series of communications go
from many of us to each other on the aspect of the evaluation of our HRE
initiatives. I have thought over it carefully and now decided that I shall
present below what we have been up to in our case. Please do find enclosed
however a brochure which should explain to each of our readers who we are.
However, since it is always known that people who read our mails are
unwilling in the first place to even open an attachment !!! I am
presenting in brief who we actually are.

This special human rights education program for children in schools is
being experimented by People's Watch - Tamil Nadu for the past 6 years,
ever since 1997.

____________________________________________________________________________ 
________
Phase	I		II		III		IV		V		VI

Period 	97-98		98-00		99-00		20-02		02-05		02-05

District	1		10		29		29		10		11

No.of Schools 9		122		238		258		134		33	

Schools	private		priv/gov/corp	TNCRI		ADW/GTR	Diocese	CSI

Class/Std.	9		8, 9		7, 8, 9		6		6		6

Students	1756		21,320		33,785		25,819		14,330		5,000

Teachers	90		315		730		492		251		80
____________________________________________________________________________ 
________
	

The table above indicates that we have covered a variety of schools from
1997 till now, increased the number of students and teachers over the
years engaged in the program, covered different regions of the state
Tamilnadu (India) in the past few years of our intervention.

Similarly, we started our experiment in the 9th standard and gradually, we
have come down to the 6th standard in the current program. Phase IV of our
human rights education program is currently being carried out in the
government Adi-Dravidar Welfare & Government Tribal Residential schools
run by the Department of Adi-Dravidar Welfare of the government of
Tamilnadu. This program is the first of its kind in the government schools
in the whole of South Asia. The Hon'ble Chairperson (Former) of the
National Human Rights Commission of India, Mr. Justice J. S. Verma
appreciated this experimental human rights education program for children
in schools through his letter to the Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu last
year in November 2002.

We also have constituted a State Level Advisory Committee on Human Rights
Education in Schools comprising of administrators, teachers and other
educators, academics and government officials.

We are a group who are known as Peoples' Watch - Tamilnadu, based in the
state of Tamilnadu in South India. We are engaged in the process of human
rights monitoring and intervention nationally and internationally and have
over the years also strayed into the arena of human rights education. Our
focus has of course been concentrating on the promotion of several
experiments in human rights education in schools in South India. In short,
we have so far carried out experiments in over 1000 schools involving over
100,000 students and over 1250 teachers in all - this is from the year
1997 onwards. We are now at a stage when this experiment is being carried
out in many a schools run by the government of Tamilnadu and we have also
received the special appreciation of the National Human Rights Commission
of India in this effort of ours.

However, let me hasten to add that we have never suffered from initiatives
on our part but really suffered in the quality executions of our programs
for the lack of resources. Now only has the government never come forward
to support us financially, within India or the state of Tamilnadu (the
resource crunch for the same being the official reason) but even funding
agencies have not found such programs for initiating the teaching of human
rights education in schools covering such a large section of students even
during the UN Decade for Human Rights Education not sufficiently useful to
them to come forward and fund.

We have not lost hope and we continue our efforts in this direction. I am
not aware of any other experiment involving such a large number of
schools, teachers and students so far in Asia dealing with a program of
human rights education in schools. The positive side of the issue is that
the government of Tamilnadu is now seriously considering at the level of
the Secretary Schools Education to see that we are entrusted a further
experiment covering all government, government aided, corporation and
Matriculations schools in the district of Dharmapuri and Sivagangai and
the Corporations of Salem, Chennai and Madurai.This would entail the
following figures in terms of our present engagement: 4000 schools, 5000
teachers and 150,000 students of the age group 11 or 12. However, the
catch really is that I also have to find the resources for this program
that is to be supported by the government!! If we are serious about the
government taking over from us, we then have to initiate the first step -
and finding resources for this important but huge steps is also our
concern. Is there anyone who is interested in assisting ??

Now coming to evaluation, we have a lot of material available with us but
which require to be processed and I am sure this would be extremely
valuable to anyone who is interested in pursuing the agenda of HRE in
schools during the Decade. The first material that we possess is also the
details of almost all the children who have passed through these years of
HRE in their schools and this data base would permit us access to at least
some of them who have completed their secondary education in school now to
find out from them and also compare these results from those students
whose students who did not have an opportunity of going through such a
human rights education program. Similarly the volume of data that we have
would also provide us the childrens' assessment of each of the teaching
modules that we have administered to them. We also have the reactions of
almost all the teachers to the carrying out of this experiment as well as
an assessment of the teachers engaged in this program by the teachers. The
data that is available would also be specially useful since it would as
well indicate what would be the reaction of the boys and girls separately
as well to the many questions that were posed to them at the end of their
course.

I am therefore participating in this long discussion that has been going
on for so long now on the evaluation of the impact of HRE only to state
that we have raw data and would look forward to at least some of you to
either come forward yourselves or come forward with willingness to make
available interns/volunteers to process large volume of data that is
available for so many years (1997-2003) now. Any volunteers coming forward
???  - institutions, researchers, resource providing agencies ??? kindly
let me know.

For those of you who are interested therefore in hard work but dealing
with experiments of human rights education in schools, here is a concrete
example.

Regards and best wishes to all of you who read this,

Henri Tiphagne, Executive Director, Institute of Human Rights Education,
People's Watch - Tamilnadu.



======== Global Human Rights Education listserv ========
Send mail intended for the list to <hr-education@hrea.org>.
Archives of the list can be found at:
http://www.hrea.org/lists/hr-education/markup/maillist.php
If you have problems (un)subscribing, contact <owner-hr-education@hrea.org>.
**You are welcome to reprint, copy, archive, quote or re-post this item,
but please retain the original and listserv source.


[Reply to this message] [Start a new topic] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index] [Subject Index] [List Home Page] [HREA Home Page]